Track changes and comments: how to review a document with other people

How track changes and comments work, how to turn them on in the apps people actually use, and a simple process that stops a review turning into chaos.

“Partnership Agreement.docx” in Quillpage on a Mac, with tracked insertions and deletions in colour and the Review pane listing a comment thread and each change with Accept and Reject

Sending a document out for feedback sounds simple. Then it comes back from three people as three different files: one with changes typed in red, one with comments in capitals in the middle of a paragraph, and one where someone has quietly rewritten your introduction. Track changes and comments exist to stop exactly that.

This guide explains how they work, how to use them in the common apps, and a few habits that make reviewing a document with other people far less painful.

What track changes and comments actually do

Track changes records every edit as a suggestion instead of making it silently. Added words appear in colour and underlined, deleted words are crossed out, and each change carries the reviewer’s name. The author then goes through and accepts or rejects each one.

Comments are notes attached to a word, sentence or paragraph and shown in the margin. They’re for questions, explanations and ideas that aren’t a simple edit, such as “Is this figure from this year?” or “Could we cut this section?” People can reply to a comment, so the discussion stays next to the text it’s about.

As a rule of thumb, use track changes for wording and corrections, and comments for anything that needs a conversation. Together they keep a full record of who suggested what, and leave the final say with the author.

How to turn on track changes in Word, Google Docs and Pages

Every major word processor has a version of this, though the names differ.

  • Microsoft Word: on the Review tab, click Track Changes (or press Ctrl+Shift+E on Windows). Add a comment with New Comment on the same tab. When you’re ready to finish, use Accept and Reject on the Review tab, one change at a time or all at once.
  • Google Docs: tracked changes are called “suggestions”. Switch from Editing to Suggesting using the mode menu at the top right. The document’s editors accept or reject each suggestion with a tick or a cross. Add a comment from the Insert menu or with Ctrl+Alt+M (⌘⌥M on a Mac).
  • Apple Pages: choose Edit, then Track Changes, and a review bar appears with Accept and Reject buttons. Add comments from the Insert menu.

Word’s tracked changes and comments are saved inside the .docx file, so they travel with it to other people and other apps that support them. When you download a Google Docs document as a Word file, its suggestions generally come through as tracked changes, which is handy when one reviewer uses Google Docs and another uses Word.

Taking turns or reviewing together

There are two ways to run a review, and both work well.

Taking turns means sending the file to one reviewer, getting it back, then sending it to the next. It’s slower but tidy, and it suits formal documents such as contracts, where each round needs to be settled before the next begins.

Reviewing together means everyone works in one shared copy, either at the same time or whenever suits them. There’s only ever one version, so nobody has to merge edits by hand. This is how Google Docs works by default, and how Word works when the file is stored in OneDrive or SharePoint.

A shared document, “Riverside Garden: Launch Plan”, with collaborators’ named cursors, the chat panel open on the right and a three-person call at the bottom right
Reviewing together in one shared copy means there’s only ever one version.

If you do send files back and forth, name them clearly so nobody edits an old copy, for example “Grant Proposal v3 (Ana’s comments).docx”. If several people send back separate copies, Word’s Compare tool on the Review tab can combine them, though it’s much easier not to need it. Our guide to working on a document together in real time covers the shared approach in more detail.

How to give feedback people can actually use

  • Set your name first. Track changes labels every edit with the name in the app’s settings. Check it before you start, so your edits don’t appear as “Author” or under someone else’s name.
  • Edit small things, comment on big ones. Fix typos and clumsy phrases directly with track changes on. For anything structural, like moving a section or changing an argument, leave a comment and let the author decide.
  • Be specific. “This is unclear” is hard to act on. “I wasn’t sure whether this means the start date or the launch date” is easy.
  • Say how much it matters. Mark a comment as essential or optional, so the author knows where to spend their time.
  • Reply, don’t repeat. If someone has already raised a point, reply to their comment rather than adding a new one beside it.
  • Leave the formatting alone unless you’ve been asked to fix it. Dozens of tiny formatting changes bury the edits that matter.

Accepting changes and finishing the document

When the feedback is in, the author works through it from the top. Most apps have Next and Previous buttons that jump from one change or comment to the next, so nothing gets missed.

  1. Read each change, then accept or reject it. Accepting makes it part of the text; rejecting puts the original wording back.
  2. Reply to comments where a decision needs explaining, then resolve or delete them once they’re dealt with.
  3. Turn track changes off before making your own final tidy-ups, or you’ll create a fresh batch of changes to review.
  4. Before you send the final version, check that no tracked changes or comments are left in the file.

That last step matters more than it sounds. A Word file with unresolved changes still carries the earlier wording and every comment, and anyone who opens it can show them. If the person receiving it shouldn’t see that history, accept or reject everything, delete the comments, or send a PDF instead.

Reviewing a document in Quillpage

Quillpage, a word processor for Mac and Windows, has the same review tools, and it saves them in the .docx file, so people using Word see your tracked changes and comments as normal. Turn on Track Changes with ⇧⌘E on a Mac or Ctrl+Shift+E on Windows, and add a comment with ⌥⌘M or Ctrl+Alt+M. The Review pane lists every comment and change with the author’s name, so you can reply to comments and accept or reject each change from one place. Set your name in Author Name so your edits are labelled correctly.

With the optional Quillpage Cloud subscription, you can also share a document and review it together live, with chat and calls inside the document. It costs £2.99 a month, and the people you invite join free, without buying Quillpage.

Whatever app you use, the habits matter more than the software: one shared version, small edits tracked, big questions in comments, and a clean file at the end. If you’re still choosing an app for this kind of work, our comparison of Word, Pages and Google Docs and our Word alternative page are good places to start.

Questions

How do I see who made a change?

Each tracked change and comment carries the name of the person who made it, shown in the margin or when you point at the change. If edits show a generic name, the reviewer hasn’t set their name in the app’s settings.

Can I accept all tracked changes at once?

Yes. In Word, open the Accept menu on the Review tab and choose Accept All Changes. In Google Docs, choose Tools, then Review suggested edits, then Accept all. Read through the changes first so nothing slips in unnoticed.

Should I use track changes or comments?

Use track changes for direct edits to the wording that the author can accept with one click. Use comments for questions, explanations and bigger suggestions that need a decision.

How do I remove all comments before sending a document?

In Word, open the Delete menu next to New Comment on the Review tab and choose Delete All Comments in Document. Accept or reject any remaining tracked changes too, or send a PDF of the final version instead.

Documents and presentations, paid for once

Quillpage opens, edits and saves Word and PowerPoint files on your Mac and Windows PC, with Quill Slides included. Try it free for 7 days, then it’s £19.99 once, on up to 3 of your devices.

Try free for 7 days

Microsoft, Word and OneDrive are trademarks of Microsoft Corporation. Google and Google Docs are trademarks of Google LLC. Apple, Mac and Pages are trademarks of Apple Inc. Quillpage isn’t made by or affiliated with Microsoft, Google or Apple.

All articles